Foundations · Guiding principles
Two rules and ten commitments
The ThoughtStretchers community is guided by two core rules and ten commitments, adapted from Jonathan Rauch’s The Constitution of Knowledge. Together they describe how a reality-based community tells knowledge apart from opinion without giving anyone the final say.
“If we care about knowledge, freedom, and peace, then we need to stake a strong claim: anyone can believe anything, but liberal science—open-ended, depersonalized checking by an error-seeking social network—is the only legitimate validator of knowledge, at least in the reality-based community.”
Jonathan Rauch, The Constitution of Knowledge (2021)
The two core rules
How a claim becomes knowledge
The fallibilist rule
No one gets the final say. You may claim that a statement is established as knowledge only if it can be debunked, in principle, and only insofar as it withstands attempts to debunk it.
The empirical rule
No one has personal authority. You may claim that a statement has been established as knowledge only insofar as the method to check it gives the same result regardless of the identity of the checker, and regardless of the source of the statement.
The ten commitments
The habits that keep the rules working
The rules say what counts as knowledge. The commitments describe how people in a reality-based community behave toward each other and toward the truth.
- FallibilismThe ethos that any of us might be wrong, so we strive to keep our ideas open to criticism.
- ObjectivityUnderstanding that truth is not based on feeling, identity, or a person’s or group’s lived experience.
- ExclusivityA commitment to the idea of objective reality, because what lies beyond that is chaos.
- DisconfirmationA commitment that all ideas and viewpoints are subject to challenge by the community.
- AccountabilityA commitment to offering our ideas for critique in good faith and acknowledging when we’re wrong.
- PluralismValuing viewpoint diversity and a commitment to encourage it and seek it out.
- CivilityA commitment to discourage and avoid personal attacks and, instead, depersonalize rhetoric.
- ProfessionalismA commitment to valuing the credentials and reputations of this reality-based community.
- InstitutionalismA commitment to valuing and relying upon established norms and codes of conduct.
- No B.S.-ingA commitment to sincerely regard the truth instead of obscuring it.
Putting them to work
- Staff meetings and board sessions. Open with the two rules, then ask which commitments your community already practices well and which it struggles with.
- Classroom norms. Post the rules and commitments on the wall and refer to them by name during discussions: “Which rule does that claim pass?”
- Contested topics. Pair them with the Objective Pluralism Discussion Protocol to separate evidence, interpretation and values.
- Policy and communication. When a polarizing issue arrives, explain decisions in terms of these commitments. See A Leader’s Guide to Culture-War Issues.